I just read an article about how the United States education system is failing our students. I believe there is a great deal of truth in this article, but it is not just the schools, it is our culture. I am afraid we American Christians have unintentionally bought into these unhealthy practices. Please, please take the time to read this article (http://www.forbes.com/sites/ericaswallow/2012/04/25/creating-innovators/), because the rest of my letter has some reflections concerning this.
This article identifies five ways in which America’s education system is stunting innovation. Let me comment on each of those:
- “Individual achievement is the focus.” However, the complex problems of today are solved by teams of individuals who collaborate and bring their expertise into the mix so that the solution is multifaceted. However, our students today have difficulty working together or even playing together. They participate on so many organized teams that on the playground they spend much of their time arguing over the game, rather than playing. They also spend much individual time on technology games where they don’t have to work together.
- “Specialization is celebrated and rewarded.” However, life is not divided into those clear-cut boundaries. Most problems and their solutions involve many different subjects. Therefore, projects that involve language, math, science, and social studies intermixed provide practice in a more real world situation. However, it is important for children to struggle in doing these problems so they learn not to give up.
- “Risk aversion is the norm.” This is probably the biggest cultural problem I see when I look at American school culture and what is important in innovation and excellence in education. You parents are very conscientious and want to support your students in their studies. However, it is very important for the student to take responsibility for their learning. Of course, that is going to mean that they will at times fail, but allowing that to happen and having the natural consequences from that is the best way for them to take ownership, especially when failure is viewed as a part of the learning process to help a student in the process of problem solving.
- “Learning is profoundly passive.” This is the one that breaks my heart. I absolutely love to see a student whose face is beaming because they have learned a new concept, something that thrills them, something that they can hardly wait to share with you. Wagner suspects that our schooling culture has actually turned us into the ‘good little consumers’ that we are. Innovative learning cultures teach about creating, not consuming.
- “Extrinsic incentives drive learning.” If all that students (and parents) are concerned about is the grade—that is extrinsic motivation and will not last. True learning should be a lifetime goal, and that is not something that you are going to measure by a letter grade. Wagner states that “fewer toys, more toys without batteries, more unstructured time in their day” results in children who grow up “to find passions, not just academic achievement.” He found that those young people want to make a difference in the world.
As I have said before in these Parent Pages, our world is desperately in need of people who are willing to make a difference. I would like to think our TCS children are going to be some of those people to do that. There is no better time than this summer to reflect on this article and apply what is being said to your views of learning. We look forward to partnering with you as we continue to “stretch for excellence” in the education of your children’s minds and the transformation of their hearts.
Summer joys to all of you,
Sue R. Meckstroth


